Kashmir heritage: Tale of a mammoth loss - Part 3

The first documented beneficiary of the government munificence was Moti Lal Nehru Children Centre (MLNCC), Lucknow

Khalid Bashir Ahmad
Srinagar, Publish Date: Jan 12 2018 11:50PM | Updated Date: Jan 13 2018 10:30AM
Kashmir heritage: Tale of a mammoth loss - Part 3File Photo

This is a column series by Khalid Bashir Ahmad focussing a crucial subject. Not only for its academic worth, this series is hugely important in understanding our contemporary crises. It brings to light the loss of history and intellectual tradition that Kashmir has suffered at the hands of inefficient bureaucracy, complicit curators, wily outsiders, and corrupt political leadership. It also captures the loss that natural disasters inflicted on Kashmir's archival wealth. Each column in the series talks about various facets of this Kashmir's national  disaster, yet cumulatively making a coherent essay on the theme of how Kashmir was robbed off its artefacts and manuscripts; how Kashmir's past was emptied to turn its future vacuous. 

A mischievous 'generosity' 

The first documented beneficiary of the government munificence was Moti Lal Nehru Children Centre (MLNCC), Lucknow

In 1995, Indian paramilitary forces during a raid on a suspected militant hideout at Chandpora, Shalimar, claimed recovery of 35 (some newspapers mentioned 32) antique objects related to 8th-10th century AD which made big news. At a press conference, the recovered antiquities were displayed. An official of the SPS Museum was called to ascertain the antiquity of the objects. “We had gone to seek custody of the recovered objects but the security forces refused to give those to us. Overnight, the antiquities were shifted to New Delhi and handed over to the National Museum”, recalls Jamshed Ahmad. The images were of Hindu deities and mostly in stone. According to a former officer of the Department of Archives, Archaeology and Museums, the objects are now on display at the National Museum.

Several incidents of theft at the SPS Museum did not come in the way of Jammu & Kashmir Government liberally gifting prized heritage objects to various museums and institutions. The first documented beneficiary of the government munificence was Moti Lal Nehru Children Centre (MLNCC), Lucknow. In 1958, the MLNCC was gifted 30 numismatics, natural history and decorative art objects. However, in 2013, when in pursuance of a court order the Government of Jammu & Kashmir was asked to get back all the gifted artefacts, the MLNCC expressed inability to locate the objects. 

Barely two months after a major theft in the Museum in 1973, as heritage lovers in Kashmir were still under shock, the State Government gave a generous gift of 35 precious artefacts, including 31 antique coins, to the Government of Himachal Pradesh for setting up a museum at Shimla. On 26 September 1973, an order was issued, pursuant to a decision of the State Cabinet headed by Chief Minister Syed Mir Qasim under which the artefacts were taken out of the SPS Museum and the Research Section of the Department of Libraries and transferred to Shimla. The objects included coins, manuscripts, armoury and painting related to ancient and medieval Kashmir. The copper and silver coins dating from the earliest Hindu period (225 AD) to the Dogra rule (1846-1947) represented the reigns of Spalapati Deva (225 AD), Tormana (500 AD), Samanta Deva (900 AD), Ananta (1028 AD), Kalasa (1081 AD), Dida (1085 AD), Harsha (1089), Zainul Aabideen (1479 AD), Fateh Shah (1483 AD), Akbar (1556 AD), Jahangir (1627 AD), Shah Jahan (1658 AD), Aurangzeb ( 1707 AD), Shah Alam (1712 AD) and Farrukh Siyar (1719 AD). Other artefacts included a Persian manuscript, Magaz un Nabi (Wars of the Prophet) by famous 16th century Kashmiri poet, scholar and spiritual personality, Sheikh Yaqoob Sarfi, one gun of the Dogra period, a Sharda manuscript and a Kashmiri painting depicting Swchanda Bhairva. 

The largest ‘gift pack’ of 209 antiquities, however, went to the newly set up Central Asian Museum of University of Kashmir in 1980. Three days after a missive from the Chief Minister’s Office, Director Archives, Libraries and Museums, on 25 August 1980, ordered that “all Central Asian Antiquities be transferred to Prof. S. Maqbool Ahmad, Director, Centre of Central Asian Studies, University of Kashmir on the day he reports in the S. P. S. Museum, Srinagar, under proper receipt. The order was “issued in pursuance of the orders of the Chief Minister.” The artefacts were taken out from textile, decorative art, archaeology and numismatics galleries. When in the light of a court directive in 2012, the SPS Museum asked for their return, the Centre of Central Asian Studies refused, arguing that these were properly transferred and registered with the Government of India under the Antiquities and Art Treasure Act of 1972 in the name of the Central Asian Museum. Subsequently, however, it relented.

Besides gifting away artefacts from its collection, the Government has exhibited casual approach towards preserving and protecting Kashmir’s heritage wealth, a glaring instance of which is sending outside the Valley ‘Stone Age’ objects for carbon dating and then caring less to bring them back. In 1963, these artefacts including stone axes and tools made of animal bones, unearthed from the Neolithic Burzahom in 1930s, were sent to a laboratory in Calcutta (now Kolkata) to scientifically determine their age. The objects were never brought back. Fifty-four years later, nobody even knows where the treasure is located now. Further excavation at Burzahom by Dr. de Terra and his team was stopped due to sinking of land there. However, the work was resumed many years later when Superintending Archaeologist Triloki Nath Khazanchi was able to unearth more Stone Age weapons. 

Old hands in Kashmir archaeology recall at least two incidents when precious artefacts were stolen from official premises. In the first case, Khazanchi had discovered a Buddha image at Harwan which was still under his study when allegedly it disappeared from his table. In another case, a 7th-8th century stone Shivlingam discovered from Parihaspora and weighing 5-6 quintals went missing from the Darbar Garh premises before it could be accessioned and transferred to the Museum. About four decades back, poet and filmmaker, Faiyaz Dilbar was doing a write up for a radio talk on heritage in which connection he visited the SPS Museum a couple of times where his attention was drawn by a small but elegant bronze statue. “It was a beautiful sculpture with Shiva in the middle and different incarnations of Vishnu around its oval shaped frame. After a fortnight, when I again visited the Museum I was shocked to see the head of Shiva missing”, he recalls. Around this time, antique traffickers in the Valley were known to be active, with a Srinagar art dealer nicknamed after a rank in one of the four suits of playing cards, allegedly being in the forefront. 

Khalid Bashir Ahmad is the author of Kashmir-Exposing the myth behind the narrative

Latest News

  1. Army man dies of cardiac arrest in north Kashmir
  2. Army man dies of cardiac arrest in north Kashmir
  1. Jammu and Kashmir: Army officer wounded in cross-LoC firing in Poonch
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: Army officer wounded in cross-LoC firing in Poonch
  1. Man arrested over murder of wife in south Kashmir: Police
  2. Man arrested over murder of wife in south Kashmir: Police
  1. Geelani condemns arrest of Bilal Kawa, says ‘Kashmiri youth implicated in false cases’
  2. Geelani condemns arrest of Bilal Kawa, says ‘Kashmiri youth implicated in false cases’
  1. Amnesty starts online and postcard campaign to petition Jammu and Kashmir CM for ban on pellets
  2. Amnesty starts online and postcard campaign to petition Jammu and Kashmir CM for ban on pellets
  1. Bijbehara shuts on maiden death anniversary of three Hizb militants
  2. Bijbehara shuts on maiden death anniversary of three Hizb militants
  1. Kashmir legislator Er Rasheed boycotts assembly, alleges beating by marshals, non-locals
  2. Kashmir legislator Er Rasheed boycotts assembly, alleges beating by marshals, non-locals
  1. 3,168 cases of crime against women registered in Jammu and Kashmir in 2017
  2. 3,168 cases of crime against women registered in Jammu and Kashmir in 2017
  1. 5,946 SPOs appointed in Jammu and Kashmir in 2017: Govt
  2. 5,946 SPOs appointed in Jammu and Kashmir in 2017: Govt
  1. Govt ends Haj subsidy from this year: Naqvi
  2. Govt ends Haj subsidy from this year: Naqvi
  1. Media persons stage walkout to protest deputy speaker's directive
  2. Media persons stage walkout to protest deputy speaker's directive
  1. JRL stages protest in Downtown Srinagar against rights violations, arrests
  2. JRL stages protest in Downtown Srinagar against rights violations, arrests
  1. Mehbooba Mufti chairs Unified High Command meeting in Jammu
  2. Mehbooba Mufti chairs Unified High Command meeting in Jammu
  1. Two injured in explosion at army’s Khundroo ammunition depot in south Kashmir
  2. Two injured in explosion at army’s Khundroo ammunition depot in south Kashmir
  1. History of referendum to be part of Goa school curriculum: CM
  2. History of referendum to be part of Goa school curriculum: CM
  1. Relatives of ‘murdered’ Sopore goldsmith protest against ‘failure’ to trace his body
  2. Relatives of ‘murdered’ Sopore goldsmith protest against ‘failure’ to trace his body
  1. Congress stages walkout from Jammu and Kashmir Assembly over Ladakh tourism projects demand
  2. Congress stages walkout from Jammu and Kashmir Assembly over Ladakh tourism projects demand
  1. People had come to kill me, claims Togadia
  2. People had come to kill me, claims Togadia
  1. Forces pay annual rent of Rs 12.38 crore for land occupied in Kashmir: Govt
  2. Forces pay annual rent of Rs 12.38 crore for land occupied in Kashmir: Govt
  1. Nawaz Sharif appears before accountability court for 13th time
  2. Nawaz Sharif appears before accountability court for 13th time
  1. Farmers body urges government to curb cigarette smuggling
  2. Farmers body urges government to curb cigarette smuggling
  1. Palestinian Central Council recommends suspending recognition of Israel
  2. Palestinian Central Council recommends suspending recognition of Israel
  1. Government forms committee to ‘examine' demands of protesting NHM employees
  2. Government forms committee to ‘examine' demands of protesting NHM employees
  1. Hit in the head, Pakistani cricketer Shoaib Malik shows symptoms of delayed concussion
  2. Hit in the head, Pakistani cricketer Shoaib Malik shows symptoms of delayed concussion
  1. Congress legislator accuses govt of making ‘unnecessary appointments’ in ‘defunct’ corporations
  2. Congress legislator accuses govt of making ‘unnecessary appointments’ in ‘defunct’ corporations
  1. Benjamin Netanyahu visits Taj Mahal
  2. Benjamin Netanyahu visits Taj Mahal
  1. Cold wave continues in Jammu and Kashmir, Kargil freezes at minus 19
  2. Cold wave continues in Jammu and Kashmir, Kargil freezes at minus 19
  1. Jammu and Kashmir minister offers to resign after allegations of corruption
  2. Jammu and Kashmir minister offers to resign after allegations of corruption
  1. Civilian injured in Shopian gunfight dies after 27 days
  2. Civilian injured in Shopian gunfight dies after 27 days
  1. NC, Congress boycott LC proceedings on second straight day; demand chairman’s apology
  2. NC, Congress boycott LC proceedings on second straight day; demand chairman’s apology
  1. Bilal Kawa arrest: Jammu and Kashmir govt afraid of Delhi, says Sagar
  2. Bilal Kawa arrest: Jammu and Kashmir govt afraid of Delhi, says Sagar
  1. Electrician found mysteriously dead in north Kashmir hospital
  2. Electrician found mysteriously dead in north Kashmir hospital
  1. Video | Uproar in assembly over arrest of Kashmiri businessman Bilal Kawa by Delhi Police
  2. Video | Uproar in assembly over arrest of Kashmiri businessman Bilal Kawa by Delhi Police