Seeking asylum abroad can't be reason for denying passport: Delhi HC

The observation by a bench of justices S Ravindra Bhat and Sanjeev Sachdeva came on an appeal by the Centre against a single judge order quashing the government''s decision to deny passports to three individuals who had sought asylum abroad.

Press Trust of India
New Delhi, Publish Date: Jan 14 2018 12:03PM | Updated Date: Jan 14 2018 12:03PM
Seeking asylum abroad can't be reason for denying passport: Delhi HCRepresentational image
Authorities cannot deny passport to an Indian citizen merely because he or she has applied for asylum in a foreign country, the Delhi High Court has said.
 
The observation by a bench of justices S Ravindra Bhat and Sanjeev Sachdeva came on an appeal by the Centre against a single judge order quashing the government's decision to deny passports to three individuals who had sought asylum abroad.
 
While upholding the single judge's order, the bench also agreed with the decision to quash the authorities act of keeping applications of such applicants under prior approval category to deny passport to them.
 
According to the trio's pleas, they had applied for political asylum in foreign countries while they were overseas, but were denied passports for five years by different passport offices in the country on the ground that they "are likely to engage in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India".
 
These decisions were based on section 6(1)(a) of the Passports Act, 1967, which provides that where "the applicant may, or is likely to, engage in such country in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India" it is a valid ground for denying passport.
 
Recognising the importance of a citizen's fundamental right to travel overseas, the high court's division bench said, "sovereignty and integrity of the country are robust concepts that can withstand the actions of isolated individuals who may seek political asylum".
 
Advocate Abhik Kumar, who has represented Satnam Singh, submitted that there were no facts indicating that any of the applicants at any time indulged in behaviour that could lead to overt action.
 
He said that they were never "part of any conspiracy with groups that sought to undermine the sovereignty and integrity of India, which was relied upon by the government in denying them passports".
 
Agreeing with their contentions, the bench observed that "the act of seeking political asylum in a foreign land, ipso facto, cannot possibly be a ground to deny passport under the Act".
 
"It is clear that the provisions of the Act should be strictly construed as they have the consequence of depriving a person of his essential rights, and such deprivation should not be done lightly, but within the confines of the legislative provision," it noted in its 18-page verdict.
 
Central government standing counsel Rajesh Gogna had submitted that the very act of applying for political asylum meant that the applicant/writ petitioner vowed allegiance to the laws and Constitution of another country and disowned the laws and Constitution of his country of birth.

Latest News

  1. Sopore gunfight: Police identifies one slain militant as Tujar Sharief resident
  2. Sopore gunfight: Police identifies one slain militant as Tujar Sharief resident
  1. CRPF man goes missing from Srinagar camp
  2. CRPF man goes missing from Srinagar camp
  1. Samsung unveils its first triple camera Smart phone Galaxy A7
  2. Samsung unveils its first triple camera Smart phone Galaxy A7
  1. Congress throwing muck, conspiring to topple me: Modi
  2. Congress throwing muck, conspiring to topple me: Modi
  1. Landslide blocks circular road in Jammu, clearance operation begins
  2. Landslide blocks circular road in Jammu, clearance operation begins
  1. Resignation of SPOs 'negligible', restricted to certain areas of south Kashmir: Govt
  2. Resignation of SPOs 'negligible', restricted to certain areas of south Kashmir: Govt
  1. Governor's rule not about deciding Article 35-A: Jammu and Kashmir govt
  2. Governor's rule not about deciding Article 35-A: Jammu and Kashmir govt
  1. Two militants killed in Sopore gunfight: Army
  2. Two militants killed in Sopore gunfight: Army
  1. Junaid Mattu resigns from NC, to contest Kashmir municipal elections
  2. Junaid Mattu resigns from NC, to contest Kashmir municipal elections
  1. Jammu and Kashmir govt asks forest dept to setup VLCs for protection of forests
  2. Jammu and Kashmir govt asks forest dept to setup VLCs for protection of forests
  1. Indo-Pak trade potential stands at USD 37 billion: World Bank
  2. Indo-Pak trade potential stands at USD 37 billion: World Bank
  1. Body of 30-yr-old man found in Srinagar
  2. Body of 30-yr-old man found in Srinagar
  1. VDC member, wife injured when rifle went off in Reasi
  2. VDC member, wife injured when rifle went off in Reasi
  1. World Bank will offer new initiative on Indus Treaty dispute: Pakistan
  2. World Bank will offer new initiative on Indus Treaty dispute: Pakistan
  1. Panchayat ghar set on fire in Bandipora, 8th such incident in valley
  2. Panchayat ghar set on fire in Bandipora, 8th such incident in valley
  1. SC extends deadline till Nov 15 for UP govt to submit vision document on protection of Taj Mahal
  2. SC extends deadline till Nov 15 for UP govt to submit vision document on protection of Taj Mahal
  1. Jammu and Kashmir: 11 drivers booked for overloading in Rajouri
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: 11 drivers booked for overloading in Rajouri
  1. Fresh exchange of fire at Sopore gunfight site
  2. Fresh exchange of fire at Sopore gunfight site
  1. Body of woman severed at head found in UP's Ballia
  2. Body of woman severed at head found in UP's Ballia
  1. Video | Govt announces one-month additional salary for employees on poll duty
  2. Video | Govt announces one-month additional salary for employees on poll duty
  1. Three Kashmir families claim kin among five militants killed in Bandipora gunfight
  2. Three Kashmir families claim kin among five militants killed in Bandipora gunfight
  1. Ganderbal family claims kin killed in Bandipora gunfight
  2. Ganderbal family claims kin killed in Bandipora gunfight
  1. Two south Kashmir families reach Bandipora, claim sons killed in Sumlar gunfight
  2. Two south Kashmir families reach Bandipora, claim sons killed in Sumlar gunfight
  1. Patna doctors' strike enters 2nd day, 12 patients dead
  2. Patna doctors' strike enters 2nd day, 12 patients dead
  1. Army pays tribute to soldier killed in Tangdhar gunfight
  2. Army pays tribute to soldier killed in Tangdhar gunfight
  1. Adobe, Microsoft and SAP announce Open Data Initiative
  2. Adobe, Microsoft and SAP announce Open Data Initiative
  1. Publicise criminal records of candidates: SC to political parties
  2. Publicise criminal records of candidates: SC to political parties
  1. JKBOSE to conduct class 11th annual examination from current session
  2. JKBOSE to conduct class 11th annual examination from current session
  1. Foreign tourist couple trapped in snow rescued in Kargil
  2. Foreign tourist couple trapped in snow rescued in Kargil
  1. Values of Nelson Mandela needed more than ever: Swaraj
  2. Values of Nelson Mandela needed more than ever: Swaraj
  1. Man dead, another injured in Kangan road mishap
  2. Man dead, another injured in Kangan road mishap
  1. Sopore shooting: searches continue in Tujjar; educational institutions closed, Internet suspended
  2. Sopore shooting: searches continue in Tujjar; educational institutions closed, Internet suspended
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine