No arrest without fair procedure, Parliament can't make such law: SC

IANS
New Delhi, Publish Date: May 16 2018 11:04PM | Updated Date: May 16 2018 11:04PM
No arrest without fair procedure, Parliament can't make such law: SC

The Supreme Court on Wednesday said that no one can be arrested without adoption of a fair procedure and that not even Parliament can make such a law, insisting that Article 21 of the Constitution on right to life and liberty has to be read in every provision of law having a bearing on the liberty of people.

"No Parliament can allow the arrest without fair procedure," said a bench of Justice Adarsh Kumar Goel and Justice Uday Umesh Lalit while pointing out that the principle of reasonableness propounded in the Maneka Gandhi case is applicable to all situations.

"If a person can be put in jail without a fair procedure, then it is just that we are not living in a civilised society," said Justice Goel.

The court was hearing the Centre's plea for recall of its March 20 judgment wherein it said that there would not be arrest of a person against whom a complaint has been filed under the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act without preliminary inquiry.

The bench, by the said judgment, had issued several directions for preliminary inquiry before an FIR is lodged and action is taken on a complaint about atrocities under the Act.

The court said that the goal of a just society and fair procedure go together and can't be seen separately and that no one can be arrested without a fair procedure and even Parliament can't frame such a law.

The court's observation came as Attorney General K.K. Venugopal tried to impress upon the court that what has been said in the judgment amounted to reading law into an existing statue, which can't be done.

The AG said that the top court can fill in the gaps in an existing law but can't add to its provision that has a bearing on its working. To buttress his point, the Attorney General took the court through its judgment in the Supreme Court Bar Association vs Union of India case.

Justice Lalit pointed to the complete machinery that was created by the top court for scrutinising the claim of a person seeking benefits of reservation under the SC/ST category. IANS

 

Latest News

  1. JK govt orders closure of offices, edu institutions tomorrow to honour Vajpayee
  2. JK govt orders closure of offices, edu institutions tomorrow to honour Vajpayee
  1. Govt announces seven-day mourning for Vajpayee
  2. Govt announces seven-day mourning for Vajpayee
  1. Vajpayee rare Indian leader who had humaneness to seek resolution of Kashmir dispute: Mirwaiz
  2. Vajpayee rare Indian leader who had humaneness to seek resolution of Kashmir dispute: Mirwaiz
  1. India lost a great son: Rahul Gandhi on Vajpayee
  2. India lost a great son: Rahul Gandhi on Vajpayee
  1. Woman drowns in Ferozpore stream in Tangmarg
  2. Woman drowns in Ferozpore stream in Tangmarg
  1. Jammu and Kashmir governor expresses grief over demise of Atal Bihari Vajpayee
  2. Jammu and Kashmir governor expresses grief over demise of Atal Bihari Vajpayee
  1. Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee dies at 93; 7-day mourning announced
  2. Former Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee dies at 93; 7-day mourning announced
  1. PDP delegation meets Governor Vohra over Article 35-A
  2. PDP delegation meets Governor Vohra over Article 35-A
  1. PM visits AIIMS again to enquire about Vajpayee's health
  2. PM visits AIIMS again to enquire about Vajpayee's health
  1. Two men claim responsibility for attack on JNU scholar Umar Khalid, post video on social media
  2. Two men claim responsibility for attack on JNU scholar Umar Khalid, post video on social media
  1. Rupee moving towards its natural value: NITI Aayog
  2. Rupee moving towards its natural value: NITI Aayog
  1. Three gamblers arrested in Srinagar: Police
  2. Three gamblers arrested in Srinagar: Police
  1. India, Pakistan troops trade fire in Tanghdar
  2. India, Pakistan troops trade fire in Tanghdar
  1. Airtel Payments Bank, Bharti AXA Life ally for govt's insurance scheme PMJJBY
  2. Airtel Payments Bank, Bharti AXA Life ally for govt's insurance scheme PMJJBY
  1. Case filed against madrasa teachers after video shows them preventing children from reciting anthem
  2. Case filed against madrasa teachers after video shows them preventing children from reciting anthem
  1. Scientists reverse congenital blindness in mice
  2. Scientists reverse congenital blindness in mice
  1. Pakistan presidential election to be held on September 4
  2. Pakistan presidential election to be held on September 4
  1. Greater Kashmir sports correspondent bereaved
  2. Greater Kashmir sports correspondent bereaved
  1. Video | Police foil SMB teachers' protest march in Srinagar
  2. Video | Police foil SMB teachers' protest march in Srinagar
  1. Pak telecom authority threatens to ban Twitter
  2. Pak telecom authority threatens to ban Twitter
  1. Gunmen attack intelligence training centre in Kabul: Officials
  2. Gunmen attack intelligence training centre in Kabul: Officials
  1. MP waterfall accident: 45 rescued, 6 missing
  2. MP waterfall accident: 45 rescued, 6 missing
  1. Kerala flood toll touches 79, rains continue
  2. Kerala flood toll touches 79, rains continue
  1. Toll soars to 48 in Kabul education centre blast
  2. Toll soars to 48 in Kabul education centre blast
  1. Nine passengers injured after matador turns turtle in Baramulla
  2. Nine passengers injured after matador turns turtle in Baramulla
  1. Beerwah village shuts on 2nd death anniversary of four civilians
  2. Beerwah village shuts on 2nd death anniversary of four civilians
  1. North Kashmir: Four army soldiers injured as gunfight breaks out near LoC in Kupwara
  2. North Kashmir: Four army soldiers injured as gunfight breaks out near LoC in Kupwara
  1. Sanctions to continue even if Turkey releases pastor Andrew Brunson: White House
  2. Sanctions to continue even if Turkey releases pastor Andrew Brunson: White House
  1. Rupee devalues to record low near 70.20
  2. Rupee devalues to record low near 70.20
  1. Non-local labourer working at Budgam brick kiln dies
  2. Non-local labourer working at Budgam brick kiln dies
  1. Jammu and Kashmir: Search operation in Rajouri after LoC skirmish
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: Search operation in Rajouri after LoC skirmish
  1. Tral residents protest poor road condition
  2. Tral residents protest poor road condition
  1. Atal Bihari Vajpayee critical, put on life-support system
  2. Atal Bihari Vajpayee critical, put on life-support system
  1. Yatra resumes after three days, 548 pilgrims leave for Amarnath cave in Kashmir
  2. Yatra resumes after three days, 548 pilgrims leave for Amarnath cave in Kashmir
  1. Umar Khalid attack: Special Cell of Delhi Police visits crime scene
  2. Umar Khalid attack: Special Cell of Delhi Police visits crime scene
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine