Lawyer Designation: Supreme Court lays down norms

“All matters relating to designation of senior advocates in the Supreme Court and in all the High Courts of the country shall be dealt with by a Permanent Committee to be known as ''Committee for Designation of Senior Advocates'',” it said.

PTI
New Delhi, Publish Date: Oct 13 2017 12:14AM | Updated Date: Oct 13 2017 12:14AM
Lawyer Designation: Supreme Court lays down normsFile Photo

The Supreme Court on Thursday laid down guidelines for itself and 24 High Courts to govern the exercise of designating lawyers as seniors and ordered setting up of a committee headed by the Chief Justice of India, which would be assisted by a secretariat.

A bench headed by Justice Ranjan Gogoi, however, rejected the plea that section 16 of the 1961 Advocates Act, which empowers the apex court or a High Court to designate senior advocates, should be held as unconstitutional.

“It is not an uncontrolled, unguided, uncanalised power, though in a given case its exercise may partake such a character. However, the possibility of misuse cannot be a ground for holding a provision of the Statute to be constitutionally fragile... Possible consequences arising from a wrong/improper exercise of power cannot be a ground to invalidate the provisions of Section 16 of the Act,” the bench, which also comprised Justices R F Nariman and Navin Sinha, said.

Disposing four petitions including one filed by senior advocate Indira Jaising, the bench, in its 112-page judgement, laid down as many as 11 guidelines to effectively deal with the process of designating lawyers as seniors.

“All matters relating to designation of senior advocates in the Supreme Court and in all the High Courts of the country shall be dealt with by a Permanent Committee to be known as 'Committee for Designation of Senior Advocates',” it said.

The panel will be headed by the CJI and consist of two senior-most Judges of the apex court or “High Court(s), as may be,” and the Attorney General or the Advocate General of a state in case of a High Court will be its member, it said.

On giving the Bar representation, it said “the four Members of the Permanent Committee will nominate another Member of the Bar to be the fifth Member of the Permanent Committee.”

The committee shall have a permanent Secretariat, the composition of which will be decided by the CJI or “the Chief Justices of the High Courts, as may be, in consultation with the other Members of the Permanent Committee”, it said.

The pleas on designating a lawyer as senior would be sent to the secretariat which would compile relevant data and information with regard to "the reputation, conduct, integrity of the Advocate(s) concerned including his/her participation in pro-bono work; reported judgements in which the concerned Advocate(s) had appeared; the number of such judgements for the last five years," it said.

It said the secretariat would collect the data and their sources for perusal and decision by the CJI-led committee.

“The Secretariat will publish the proposal of designation of a particular Advocate in the official website of the concerned Court inviting the suggestions/views of other stakeholders in the proposed designation,” it said.

After compilation of data-base, the information may be sent to the permanent committee for scrutiny, it said, adding “the permanent committee will examine each case in the light of the data provided by the secretariat of the permanent committee; interview the concerned advocate; and make its overall assessment on the basis of a point-based format.”

The apex court said that 100 points would be awarded under different heads to the lawyers seeking consideration for being designated as seniors.

Maximum of 20 points would be earmarked for the years spent in the legal profession, it said, adding that 40 points would be given for aspects such as judgements to which the lawyer has been a part, pro-bono litigations, domain of expertise in branches of law.

Publications by the Applicant Advocate would be earmarked 15 points, while the test of personality and suitability on the basis of interview or interaction would have 25 points.

All the names listed before the Permanent Committee or cleared by it, will go to the Full Court comprising all judges of concerned High Courts or the apex court for approval, it said.

"Voting by secret ballot will not normally be resorted to by the Full Court, except when unavoidable. In the event of resort to secret ballot, decisions will be carried by a majority of the Judges who have chosen to exercise their preference/choice," it said.

If a lawyer, whose bid to become a senior has been rejected, can be considered for the same after expiry of two years of such rejection.

If a senior lawyer is found to be guilty of misconduct, "the Full Court may review its decision to designate the concerned person and recall the same," it said.

The bench said the guidelines may not be exhaustive and "may require reconsideration in the light of the experience to be gained over a period of time."

 PTI 

 

Latest News

  1. Wheel-chair bound Kashmiri receives NCPEDP award in Delhi
  2. Wheel-chair bound Kashmiri receives NCPEDP award in Delhi
  1. Narrow escape for passengers as Kuwait Airways flight lands 'off centre' in Kochi
  2. Narrow escape for passengers as Kuwait Airways flight lands 'off centre' in Kochi
  1. Reliance Jio announces JioPhone 2 flash sale from Thursday
  2. Reliance Jio announces JioPhone 2 flash sale from Thursday
  1. I don't believe in soft or hardcore Hindutva: Rahul
  2. I don't believe in soft or hardcore Hindutva: Rahul
  1. Video | Cloudburst triggers flash flood in Karnah in north Kashmir’s Kupwara
  2. Video | Cloudburst triggers flash flood in Karnah in north Kashmir’s Kupwara
  1. PDP leader Waheed Parra escapes unhurt after gunmen attack his vehicle in Budgam
  2. PDP leader Waheed Parra escapes unhurt after gunmen attack his vehicle in Budgam
  1. Another accident victim dies in Poonch; death toll now 4
  2. Another accident victim dies in Poonch; death toll now 4
  1. Delhi Police Spl Cell takes over probe into Umar Khalid attack case
  2. Delhi Police Spl Cell takes over probe into Umar Khalid attack case
  1. Four killed in flash floods in Jammu
  2. Four killed in flash floods in Jammu
  1. Jammu and Kashmir: Woman Vaishno Devi pilgrim dies in Reasi
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: Woman Vaishno Devi pilgrim dies in Reasi
  1. Jammu and  Kashmir: Two people electrocuted in Samba
  2. Jammu and Kashmir: Two people electrocuted in Samba
  1. Funeral prayers in absentia held for Maqbool Bhat’s associate
  2. Funeral prayers in absentia held for Maqbool Bhat’s associate
  1. Taliban militants overrun Afghan Army base, 17 soldiers killed
  2. Taliban militants overrun Afghan Army base, 17 soldiers killed
  1. Airtel announces special Amazon pay gift card for customers
  2. Airtel announces special Amazon pay gift card for customers
  1. Video | Man detained while attempting to hoist tri-color at Lal Chowk
  2. Video | Man detained while attempting to hoist tri-color at Lal Chowk
  1. Non-local vendor tries to ‘abduct’ minor girl in Kupwara, arrested
  2. Non-local vendor tries to ‘abduct’ minor girl in Kupwara, arrested
  1. Pakistan remembers Kashmiris, their historic sacrifices: Mamnoon Hussain on I-Day
  2. Pakistan remembers Kashmiris, their historic sacrifices: Mamnoon Hussain on I-Day
  1. Governor asks CS to consider early release of SSA teachers' salaries
  2. Governor asks CS to consider early release of SSA teachers' salaries
  1. Army pays tribute to soldier killed in north Kashmir's Kupwara
  2. Army pays tribute to soldier killed in north Kashmir's Kupwara
  1. Jammu and Kashmir Governor condoles demise of Somnath Chatterjee
  2. Jammu and Kashmir Governor condoles demise of Somnath Chatterjee
  1. Video | ‘Azadi from drugs’ rally organised in Baramulla
  2. Video | ‘Azadi from drugs’ rally organised in Baramulla
  1. US hopes to strengthen ties with Pakistan: Pompeo
  2. US hopes to strengthen ties with Pakistan: Pompeo
  1. SC to hear plea of 300 Army personnel challenging FIR against them in AFSPA areas
  2. SC to hear plea of 300 Army personnel challenging FIR against them in AFSPA areas
  1. Rupee hits record low against US dollar
  2. Rupee hits record low against US dollar
  1. Turkey crisis risks souring military ties with US
  2. Turkey crisis risks souring military ties with US
  1. Two Pakistani soldiers killed in retaliatory fire in Tangdhar: Army
  2. Two Pakistani soldiers killed in retaliatory fire in Tangdhar: Army
  1. North Kashmir: India, Pakistan exchange fire along LoC in Tanghdar
  2. North Kashmir: India, Pakistan exchange fire along LoC in Tanghdar
  1. Traffic suspended after landslides on Kashmir highway
  2. Traffic suspended after landslides on Kashmir highway
  1. Man arrested in connection with Kanwariya vandalism in Delhi
  2. Man arrested in connection with Kanwariya vandalism in Delhi
  1. Shehla Rashid files complaint against Ravi Poojary for threatening her
  2. Shehla Rashid files complaint against Ravi Poojary for threatening her
  1. Israel, Egypt held secret meeting over Gaza in May: Report
  2. Israel, Egypt held secret meeting over Gaza in May: Report
  1. Pakistan celebrates Independence Day with patriotic zeal, fervour
  2. Pakistan celebrates Independence Day with patriotic zeal, fervour
x
This site uses cookies to deliver our services and to show you relevant news and ads. By using our site, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy, and our Terms of Service.That's Fine